The Best Shops for High-Quality Cheddar Cheese

Not all cheddar is created equal. There's a world of difference between the shrink-wrapped blocks at the grocery store and the complex, crystalline, aged cheddar produced by artisan cheesemakers. Here's how to find the real thing.

What Makes Great Cheddar?

The best cheddar is aged for at least 12 months, made from high-quality milk, and allowed to develop naturally. Look for a firm texture with visible protein crystals — a sign of proper aging.

Cheddar Worth Seeking Out

Montgomery's Cheddar from Somerset, England is widely considered the world's finest. Cabot Clothbound Cheddar from Vermont is the best American cheddar available. Keen's Cheddar is another Somerset classic with a bold, tangy depth.

Build the Perfect Cheese Board

Pair aged cheddar with our Artisan Manchego and our Échiré French Butter for a stunning spread.

Great cheddar is a revelation. Seek it out and you'll never go back.